Batman has always been one of the public’s favorite heroes, passed down from generation to generation. No wonder The Dark Knight trilogy is still close to many people’s hearts today. But it was the villainous Joker who really stole the show in the second movie, thanks to Heath Ledger’s iconic performance. The actor even won a posthumous Oscar for Best Supporting Actor, proving that his work is seen by many critics as one of the most brilliant in movie history. Even though there have been many versions of Batman’s archenemy over time, most fans also consider Ledger’s Joker to be the best of them all. But things were very different when Ledger’s name was first linked to the Joker role. Early on, there was almost no faith in the star’s work.
Videos by ComicBook.com
Christopher Nolan, director of the project, faced a lot of backlash over casting Ledger, as the vast majority of fans and critics didn’t believe it would work. The main reason was that the Joker is a sadistic and maniacal villain, while Ledger’s previous work hadn’t shown his ability to play such a character. This kind of reaction isn’t unusual, especially when it comes to major figures in pop culture and entertainment; when it comes to official casting announcements, the Internet is unforgiving. People often judge the book by its cover, but Heath Ledger’s Joker will always be a great example of how it’s worth waiting for a production to premiere before forming a genuine opinion.
The Criticisms of Heath Ledger as Joker Were Severe
Christopher Nolan is a renowned filmmaker, and it’s no wonder that his latest project is already eagerly awaited by many. However, even before he established himself as one of cinema’s geniuses, many people didn’t seem to have trust in him. Nolan was the only one to trust Ledger’s work as a supporting actor in his Batman crime drama, and even with criticism coming from all sides, he stuck to his decision from start to finish. His brother, Jonathan Nolan, co-scripted The Dark Knight and even gave an interview to The Hollywood Reporter, where he opened up about the skepticism over Ledger:
“When I wrote The Dark Knight, Chris [Nolan] had to figure out how we’d tackle the Joker. Chris had a good meeting with Heath Ledger. And no one got it – I didn’t get it, the studio didn’t get it. And the fan community was… we were f*cking pilloried for it. ‘Disaster, worst casting decision ever!’” he said.
However, Jona revealed that his brother knew exactly that the right thing to do was not to listen to the public, almost as if he knew that the actor’s performance would surprise everyone and make them regret criticizing the casting: “Chris just stuck to his guns. It was a question of not giving the fans what they’re asking for but what they want – which is, ‘Let’s find a really f-ckin’ serious actor, somebody who’s going to come in and just tear this role to pieces’.”
[RELATED: Does Joker: Folie à Deux Finally Reveal the True Origin of Heath Ledger’s Joker?]
The 2008 film had Ledger announced as a supporting actor in 2006, and even though it’s been a long time, you can still find some comments from fans on forums from back then. “The whole movie depends on this casting. They’d better do it well. And Heath Ledger has the charisma of a lettuce leaf,” said one user. “Christopher Nolan isn’t an idiot, he’s not going to cast this cowboy,” said another, referring to Ledger’s role in Brokeback Mountain. One genre very present in Ledger’s filmography was romance and rom-coms, which was the main reason many believed he wouldn’t be able to take on a more serious role requiring a different commitment, especially since the Joker is such a dark character.
There was even heavier backlash: “Heath Ledger is an embarrassment to all Australians,” said one user. Another went even further. “Please… No. The Joker is a character that needs an actor with gravity. Not some little twerp who got lucky.” On the other hand, years after the film’s release, some people have decided to recognize how wrong they were. “I laughed my damn head off. I thought it was going to fail miserably. The pretty boy lead of Brokeback Mountain playing the Joker? Come onnnnnn. And then the first picture came out and I thought he looked like a tryhard idiot. Then I saw the opening scene at the bank that was released earlier and he instantly won me over,” a Reddit user said.
Ten years after Ledger’s death, Nolan spoke to BBC Radio 1 about the actor’s preparation for playing the character. The director considered his Joker to be terrifying, highlighting Ledger’s dedication to surprising everyone with his characterization. Much – if not all – of the Joker’s creative development was Ledger’s, from the make-up to the costumes, but the standout was his improvisation on set. Nolan explained that the applause scene and the variations in his voice were always unexpected. The strange and unique tone was something others tried to imitate afterward, but it never had the same impact. The scariest thing was the fact that no one really knew what he could do next, and perhaps that was exactly what made the filmmaker see the potential in him.
Ledger became a legend for knowing how to be unpredictable. The Joker needed that.
The Lesson to Be Learned from Heath Ledger’s Case in The Dark Knight
The audience for comic book adaptations is a type that always expects impeccable work and is rigid most of the time. However, they have also been proven wrong many times. Robert Pattinson’s Batman is an example of this, considering that the actor was, for a long time, linked to the Twilight saga. For many, that work discredited him from being able to embody Bruce Wayne in the expected way, even though he had already played more serious characters before Matt Reeves’ project. Michael Keaton’s casting as Batman similarly shocked many, as he was thought of as a quirky, comedic actor up to that point. Ledger shows to this day that early judgments can be extremely wrong, and that it’s important to keep an open mind when faced with unconventional castings. You never know what might come out of it.
The actor’s dedication and talent transformed the initial negative perception into universal acclaim, and today many actors are inspired by his work, which is no small feat. It is necessary to see the final result before forming a definitive opinion. Not all talent fits expectations, but sometimes it simply redefines the narrative. After all, when it comes to The Dark Knight, it’s more common to remember Ledger than Christian Bale.
The Dark Knight is streaming on Max.
